Building comfort optimization

How to Enhance Building Comfort Levels Without Increasing Energy Costs

Comfort complaints are often treated by lowering the setpoint, which costs energy and rarely fixes the cause. A better approach is to find what is really wrong. This guide covers the usual causes and the fixes that cost little.

What comfort is made of

ASHRAE Standard 55 describes thermal comfort as a mix of air temperature, radiant temperature, humidity, air movement, clothing and activity. A room can read the right temperature and still feel wrong because one of the others is off. Ask the occupant what they feel before you change a setting.

Common causes and low-cost fixes

ComplaintLikely causeWhat to check
Too hot or too cold in one roomAirflow does not match designMeasure the airflow at the room’s outlets
Thermostat says fine, people disagreeSensor in a poor spot or out of calibrationCompare it to a reference thermometer
Cold draftsSupply air too cold or too fast at the diffuserCheck supply temperature and airflow at the outlet
Stuffy or clammyHigh humidity or too little ventilationCheck humidity and outdoor air
Warm in the afternoonSolar gain, or zone cannot keep upCheck the zone’s maximum airflow

Fixes that save energy as well

  • Balance the airflow. Rooms with too little air get complaints, and the usual response is to cool the whole building harder. See how balancing affects building performance.
  • Move or recalibrate the sensor. It should not sit in sun, near a supply outlet or on an exterior wall.
  • Use a wider deadband. A gap between heating and cooling setpoints stops the system from fighting itself.
  • Reduce unnecessary reheat. Check the minimum airflow setting on each variable air volume box.
  • Schedule the system. Run it for the hours the space is used.

Measure before you change

Take temperature readings in the complaint area at occupant height for a few days. Compare them with the thermostat. This tells you whether the problem is the room, the sensor or the expectation. For a systematic approach, see our guide to troubleshooting temperature imbalances.

A simple way to run a comfort investigation

  1. Log the complaint: location, time of day, what the person feels.
  2. Put a temperature and humidity logger in the area for a few days.
  3. Measure airflow at the outlets serving the space and compare with design.
  4. Check the thermostat location and calibration.
  5. Look at the zone’s controls for overrides or wrong setpoints.
  6. Fix the cause, then log again to confirm.

Most complaints are solved by step 3 or 4. If airflow is far from design, a balance fixes the actual cause and removes the pressure to overcool the whole building.

What not to do

  • Do not lower the setpoint for the whole building to fix one room.
  • Do not close dampers in a room that is too cold without checking where the air goes. It may push the problem somewhere else.
  • Do not ignore humidity. A room can be at the right temperature and still feel clammy.

Questions facility managers ask about comfort

What temperature should we aim for?

ASHRAE 55 describes a comfort range that depends on humidity, clothing, activity and air movement, not a single number. Agree a range for the building, then adjust by area and by season using the complaints and logger data you collect.

Will a wider deadband bother occupants?

Usually not, if you widen it gradually and the airflow is even. Complaints often come from uneven air, not from the setpoint itself.

Is humidity part of comfort?

Yes. High humidity feels warm and clammy, and very low humidity dries skin and eyes. If a room reads the right temperature and still gets complaints, measure the humidity.

Related reading: Ventilation and Sleep: Hotels, Dorms and Care Facilities.

If rooms in your building never settle, a measured air balance can find out why. Call Ghazi Hussain at (908) 323-9780.

Need Help?

Ghazi-Hussain-Air-Balance-Masters